Wacky thought? Perhaps not!

As posted by Abby Crocker on Facebook 4/5/16

Here is a totally wacky thought. Just for discussions sake, let’s say the School Board hears loud and clear “we want our 3 elementary schools”. We are then left with the planning process for how to really make our 3 elementary schools work, within the context of our growing city.

We could keep our 3 current schools, prioritizing them as historic, valuable, healthy anchors of our communities. Central would be at the heart of our city center and our municipal facilities (i.e. library and rec) could potentially be developed in the UMall, taking advantage of the UVM arena space (also in the UMall). The UMall is ugly and outdated and we are SO fortunate that the owner recognizes this and wants to improve it, and the TIF map can be redrawn to ensure the city maximizes the financial gain from these developments.

Or, we could repurpose Central for the rec dept and library…making these facilities the heart of the City Center. We could redistrict school lines, really work to create a pedestrian/bike friendly crossing at Williston road to bridge communities together, and move Central school to the Oak Creek site. Oak Creek could potentially work for a single elementary school.

Comments
John Thomas  John Thomas Anchors indeed. I also like cultural/heritage pinions.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby Sounds to me like Abby Crocker needs to run for MAYOR! smile emoticonBut seriously, THANK YOU for getting this open minded conversation going!
Paul Engels  Paul Engels The problem with Central becoming a library or rec center is that property in that part of town is worth $1-$1.5 million per acre making the 10 acres there worth as much as $15 million. The property belongs to the school district so the city would have to acquire it to repurpose it. In short, it would be a very expensive library or rec center.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby I do think it comes down to the cost of building new – especially outside of the TIF. Whether for a larger or smaller school. $$$. The City offered a land swap to the Schools Center for Oak Creek. But the building costs…
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Isn’t the UMall within the TIF district now? What are the pros/cons of putting the library and rec center there? If the UVM arena goes in the UMall it would be nice to have the rec center near it.
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp This is a solid idea. I support both as the concept of preserving our K-5 elementary schools is kept intact. Great idea, Abby Crocker!
Laurel Williams  Laurel Williams I really like this, Abby Crocker! You’re reframing from debate over what we don’t want, and instead asking us to dream up what we really do want.
Paul Engels  Paul Engels UMall is not within the TIF district. Keep in mind that public buildings like an arena, library and a rec center do not produce tax revenue. Property tax on property that is a million dollars an acre is a lot of money. Inside the TIF district, these taxes on private properties will pay for the public properties.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker So, it sounds like the TIF district lines are being expanded to include the UMall. Where do you think, the library/rec center should go?
Cheryl Hooper-Feeney  Cheryl Hooper-Feeney Abby, your last paragraph, has been talked about since a master planning/visioning committee met in 1983-1987!
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Tracey Harrington I thought the TIF lines were being expanded to include the UMall…did you mention something to this extent earlier? Can you clarify (if you know, if not I’ll ask a CC). Thanks!
Tracey Harrington  Tracey Harrington The UMall is not within the current TIF district but those lines can be expanded/redrawn and there have been discussions during our meetings about doing so. I’ll ask for an update and get back to the group.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Thanks Tracey!
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby Tracey – The City Council did vote to seek that it be added. But not sure what the process is.

 

“…maximize the noise mitigation and make sure that it is safe for our kids OR we can close Chamberlin.”

As posted on Facebook by Ray Gonda 4/5/16

In answer to Abby’s comment about sound-proofing Chamberlin School: This is a fools task. The Air Force itself admits as much in its final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS). Put simply, it states that sound-insulation of residences is not very effective.

A local resident has super-sound-proofed his home and is very disappointed with the results. He feels that the only way it would be effective is if the windows would also be boarded up. Chamberlin School is little different in this regard from residences.

And what protection would be afforded to children in the school yard? It isn’t rare for them to cry and some even scream from the sound of those jets – at least as of three year ago when I walked around and surveyed over 300 houses asking opinions about the F-35 coming there. Such noise levels in children can be pure physical pain.

Likewise for several sets of young parents whose children after two years there were still scared of them – even though they stopped being absolutely terrified. That too was within the 65 dB DNL zone.

A second point to be clear on is that Chamberlin school lies within the 65 db DNL (day-night average) noise zone (likely at about 70) on every noise exposure map that has been published to date. Than means significant health effects particularly on cognitive impairment of children according to the World Health Organization and many other studies. Ditto for children’s hearing problems due to the smaller ear canal than adults and how it intensifies the sound. That is the lowest noise level that the Air Force classifies as “not fit for residential use”. Any point inside the 65 dB DNL contour is higher than 65 dB DNL. Chambrerlin is at about 70 dB DNL.

It is also within a sufficiently high noise zone such that, statistically, one would expect a minimum of 3.5% more hospital visits would be expected for residents in that one age 65 or older due to cardiac reasons at the beginning edge of that 65 zone and climbing from there). Another way to state it is that, for each 10 dB DNL increase, 3.5% more cardiac-related hospital visits are incurred.

I hate to make this statement because I would much rather see Chamberlin remain in place since this is my neighborhood (I live within sight of it), but children would be much better off farther away from the airport and the military jets.

I would prefer to see the military jets go, not Chamberlin School.
My stepson came up through the public school grades beginning there. The best solution would be the retain Chamberlin but bring a less noise-intrusive mission to the Air Guard. Perhaps wishful thinking.

APR6

Today 7 PM · FHTMS Library
Comments
Linus Leavens  Linus Leavens Chamberlin Elementary School is very different from a wood frame house. It is multiple cinder block wall construction. The roofing, being flat, could be retro-engineered to a pitched roof with baffling. The low frequencies, however, would still resonate. Timing of takeoffs to minimize impact would be useful. How about no more afternoon launches perfectly timed to coincide with when the kids are getting out of school, USAF? Recesses without takeoffs. You know. Common sense decisions. Unlike the present.
Ray Gonda  Ray Gonda Timing sounds like a good idea Linus. HOWEVER, I am skeptical the Air Guard would or could do such a task in that their air operations may not have the flexibility to coordinate with the local school. They certainly have not been responsive to the many hundreds of complaints about noise events. 
The F-35 is reported to have a lower pitched roar that the F-16s indicating lower frequencies.

Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker It seems like everyone we hear from talks about how valuable and cherished Chamberlin school is to the neighborhood and the city. I haven’t heard anyone say they feel the education received there is at all subpar – in fact on more than one occasion I’ve heard that it is the “best in SB”. That being said, the airport & F16s are noisy and the school falls within the >65db noise level line. Thus, some feel this is “too noisy” for a school and others say “its not too noisy to justify removing the school from the community”. My concern is that if it IS the airport noise that is at all driving the decision to close Chamberlin then there should be more to compensate the city for the loss of such a valuable school and valuable neighborhood asset. Currently, the only offer on the table is for noise mitigation. So, we can either work to protect Chamberlin and maximize the noise mitigation and make sure that it is safe for our kids OR we can close Chamberlin. If its the latter, I would hope that we would do more than just sell the property to a developer…I would hope that we would seek appropriate compensation for the loss of such a valuable part of our community, as closing Chamberlin would have many direct and indirect impacts throughout the Chamberlin neighborhood as well as our entire city.

What educational elements can a bong fund?

As posted on Facebook by Monica Ostby 4/5/16

What educational elements can a bond fund? AND – Is a one-time budget increase ‘penalty tax’ the way to go???

Martin LaLonde provides this answer:

“I have tracked down the answer the questions you raised regarding how the proceeds of a bond may be used. Bonds are primarily available to finance “improvements” (24 VSA 1751(3)), which are defined by statute to be capital improvements or assets. Section 1752 of Title 24 also states that no bonds shall be issued for “ordinary expenses” except as specifically permitted. The specifically permitted exceptions are borrowings in anticipation of tax receipts (24 VSA 1786) or in anticipation of grants in aid (24 VSA 1773(c)). Since expenses associated with a language program are operational in nature, and not capital, bond financing is not an available funding source. Thanks for asking the question, but it doesn’t look like it is a viable funding option.”

I followed up with these questions:
1. Are there other things that are currently part of the school budget that could be instead covered “for ten years” by a bond, allowing for such things to fit within the allowable increase?

2. IF in YR1 (say 2017) voters agree to increase a school budget that increases by an above the cap increase, but in YR2 (say 2018) it only increases within the cap, does YR2 get hit with the penalty fee again because the YR1 increase is not resolved? Is that clear? Perhaps a one-time, penalized adjustment would be more efficient – and enable the ed improvements David is proposing to fit within future budgets?

Comments:

Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Lingering questions for me are:

1) Can we do better with what we have?
We just passed a school budget of nearly $47million, which include funding some the highest paid teachers and administrators in the state. We do this because we care about our childrens’ education and have high expectations for those providing it. We are paying top dollar for everything…can’t we take a look at the existing budget and ask are we getting our dollars worth? Where can we do better? And, if we NEED to invest more how can we leverage that investment to have the greatest impact.

2) Are there alternatives sources of funding we can consider?
I just heard that Mt Mansfield is using grant dollars to support the foreign language programs. There are grant and foundation opportunities out there…why can’t we try to take advantage of some of them?

What do folks think about option #3?

As posted by Abby Crocker 4/5/16

Given the $64million price tag, the lack of evidence supporting the educational benefits, and the negative impact on neighborhoods I am thinking that the proposed option #5 (close all elementary schools and build an 800+ person school on Oak Creek) isn’t really a consideration (totally respect that others may disagree).

What do folks think of option #3? This is the option to close Chamberlin, renovate Central and Orchard to accommodate more students (~400 each), move 5th graders to the middle school (which would also require renovations). The estimated cost for this is $36million.

For me, the questions that option #3 raises are:
1. Why target Chamberlin as the school to close? There is federal funding to help mitigate noise at the school and the noise levels have not deemed the school “unusable”. If noise levels actually did deem the school “unusable” shouldn’t there be more compensation?

2. By creating two schools with 400 students in each, aren’t we maxing out the capacity of the schools right off the bat? The estimated 400 students in each school is based on current K-4 enrollments and assumes that the school population will remain stagnant or perhaps drop slightly. However, what if families move into all this housing we are creating (city center alone will be 70% housing)? What if the school population goes up by 100 students in the next 25 years…then all of a sudden we have two over crowded schools.

3. What exactly are the educational benefits of reducing to two elementary schools and moving the 5th graders to the middle school? And, how can these outcomes be achieved by spending $36mill on buildings? How could these outcomes be achieved if we chose to spend $9mill to maintain our current facilities and invest in programming instead?

 Comments:
Matt Boulanger  Matt Boulanger I’m not sure where I land on may of the big-picture issues discussed around the school reconfiguration question, but I can say that I doubt attached dwelling units as are likely to be built in City Center will generate many school-aged children. In Williston where I work, there has been much doom and gloom cast about that the new projects bringing density and attached dwelling units will “overwhelm the schools” with kids, but so far that just hasn’t played out. It’s the new single-family, medium-to-large lot stuff that generates School-aged kids, where a place like Finney Crossing (at probably 175 attached units and 30 or so single-family homes) has so far generated about three kids in the school system.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker I agree that young families tend to be looking for affordable, single family homes with yards. There are numerous single family home neighborhoods being developed and expanded in SB as well (i.e. Rye, South Village, Cider Mill, etc) and I would hope that these would be houses that families would be interested in. Personally, I live in a multifamily dwelling and it really works for our family. But, it’s a really well designed community….private entrances and back decks, community playground (love that all the kids go to one structure rather than everyone having their own in a fenced in backyard), community fields, etc. Multifamily dwellings can be really cost-effective and attractive to young families if designed right. I agree – not sure if that design approach fits in with the city center vision.
Erin Hooper Sutherland  Erin Hooper Sutherland I agree closing all schools at a price tag of $64 million is out of the question. I too am not opposed to two elementary schools however have these same questions. I worry south Burlington population is not decreasing and over crowded schools will happen. Closing chamberlain seems very sad as that school IS the heart of the hood. I do support moving 5th to middle school if done thoughtfully.
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll Haven’t we already been down this road of moving the 5th grade to the Middle school? I don’t understand why the board would go that route after the opposition it faced last time. Just my thoughts. Also, maybe the school age population won’t increase but why would we leave ourselves with no room for error?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman My children attended Camel’s Hump Middle School in Richmond from 5th to 8th grades. The schools in Chittenden East School District were 1-4, 5-8, 9-12. The fifth grade in the middle school worked well.
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll David Young brought up moving 5th grade a couple of years ago and decided to explore other options because there was an overwhelming amount of people opposed to the idea. I just don’t understand why you would try the option again, for a second time, just two years later?

 Maybe when faced with an either/or option, people would prefer to move the 5th grade over consolidating to 1 elementary school?

Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker –  Kate Griffin Nahstoll I think you’re right. If I HAD to choose between a single K-4 800+ person school for $64million and two K-4 400+ person schools for $36million, I’d choose the latter. BUT we don’t HAVE to choose between those two. Option #1 – keep our three K-5 elementary schools and invest $9million in a continued stewardship plan is on the table.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby The impact to the Chamberlin neighborhood of losing its school is significant to every property owner there. It seems a very premature move at this time. Especially if @city center” is to be the future home of all library/rec/etc, leaving no municipal opportunity for the Chamberlin land? ALSO I’d like clarification on OPTION 2 – which I believe renovates ALL 5 SB schools to “21st Century Learning”. Seems like the most efficient plan for the next 10 years, in which time hopefully the real “impact” of city center and any potential changes un the airport area are KNOWN and not just EDTIMATED. Our schools should not be the first of the dominos to fall. And I’d much rather know that a city bond to support our library and rec department can be secured. Priorities!!!
Paul Engels  Paul Engels I doubt that there is enough usable property at Oak Creek to build an 800+ school.
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman I have heard that also.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker –  Paul Engels – I think I remember as part of the Task Force we were told that about 7-8 acres of the 10 acre Oak Creek property might be usable (due to wetland issues). Thus, we would need a 3 story building to accommodate 800+ students. In addition, we…See More
Paul Engels  Paul Engels That is what I recall too, Abby. Apparently there is a cliff as well as wetlands and no room for playing fields. Walking that property would be an interesting field trip.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Agreed! I think it was even suggested that the kids “could walk to Dorset Park” for their playing fields. It’s this logic that made me question if there was an intent to “expand” into Wheeler Nature Area for the proposed school site, after all Wheeler is immediately adjacent to the Oak Creek property and is city owned. This is why the Wheeler Nature permanent conservation easement is so important (so glad this is underway with the commitment to conserve the entire property). We need to stop thinking of our natural areas as “free potential development sites”.
Brandy Paul  Brandy Paul 1. I live in Chamberlin neighborhood and have a kindergartener at Chamberlin and a 2 1/2 year old who, I hope, will be going to Chamberlin, so no surprise that right now, at least until I hear a good argument for doing so, I’m not in favor of closing our school. The neighborhood school was the major factor in purchasing our home. My own gut feeling is that, without our school, our neighborhood goes downhill. It is NOT “the other side of the tracks” as I sadly heard it referred to recently however, my fear is that it will become that if we lose the attraction of our school. If noise levels deem the school “unusable,” I’d like to hear more discussion on that. I’m for what’s best for the students but, currently, it’s not unusable. I’m not necessarily inflexible on this but, as of now, I’m not hearing enough to justify closing Chamberlin, especially at the price tag stated.

2. I also have worries about consolidating into 2 schools – overcrowding the schools, potential increase in class sizes, the sense of feeling lost for the younger kids in such a big school. With the higher standards and assessments that even kindergartners are affected by, I just worry about a negative impact. I’d have to hear more on how the logistics would work. With 400 students in each school, does that mean the children now only have 10 minutes to rush through lunch with their coats on (ready for recess or just coming back from) instead of the 15 – 20 in order to push them all through? I’m not necessarily against any consolidation but would have to hear some guarantees on the logistics. A kindergarenter/1st grader, etc. shouldn’t be stressed about their day but some are already. Would potential over-crowding make it worse? What are the educational benefits, not just the dollar benefits?
3. I don’t love the idea of moving 5th graders to the middle school, however I admittedly don’t have a 5th grader yet so I’m not sure whether my opinion may change as mine get older. My husband works in an elementary school in another town and also directs the after-school program (3rd – 8th graders for after-school program) and he cringed at thought of moving 5th graders into a middle school with 8th graders, as did two different neighbors who I spoke with, one who is a teacher in another town and one who has 3 children in 1st, 5th and 8th grades. There just seems to be too much of an age/maturity gap and I’m not convinced there are benefits to putting 5th graders with 8th graders that outweigh the current structure.

Emilee DiFerdinando Hoffman  Emilee DiFerdinando Hoffman Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Brandy. I agree with a lot of what you have to say. And I was also appalled by the way Chamberlin was described as being on the “other side of the tracks” in the Task Force Report. Totally disrespectful and untrue. That single line really showed the privileged and out-of-touch tone of the entire report. We have amazing schools in South Burlington. To suggest that we can’t do right by our kids unless we spend millions and millions of dollars is obtuse and unimaginative.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker –  Brandy Paul – I SO encourage you to share your thoughts with the school board about how important Chamberlin is to the Chamberlin neighborhood. I totally agree. The Chamberlin neighborhood has single family homes with yards, with an amazing elementary school at its heart. Kids can walk to this school. I was amazed to hear that Chamberlin has a monthly family movie night. THAT is community!!!! THAT is amazing. If you take the school away what would need to take its place in order to make the neighborhood thrive? Could something “replace” a school? It’s important to note that all of the options put forth by the school board that close Chamberlin reflect selling Chamberlin to developers. Thus, we could anticipate something like doctors offices going there. What does that do for the future of the neighborhood?
Emily Frazier Williams  Emily Frazier Williams I absolutely do not support moving 5th grade to middle school– at that age I’d prefer my kids still be getting plenty of recess and childhood time rather than being exposed to middle school… I don’t want them emulating 12 and 13 yr olds in this day and age!
Brandy PaulBrandy PaulExactly! I just don’t see good coming out of rushing them to middle school. I actually forgot about the recess issue. I had heard from a parent in another school district that there is no recess time for middle school. Sounds like it is the same for SB.
Monica OstbyMonica OstbyFurther to my comment (below) about the 5th grade move… There are really cool – age appropriate – opportunities on the beautiful 500 Dorset St campus. I was trying to organize daily supervised CAMPUS WALKS through the woods/wetlands using parent volunteers. FREE. It takes a lot of coordination and community involvement – and just isn’t the focus of the current administration. My current 4th grader is so ready to be at FHTMS. I think its a matter of how – and doing it right… IF it comes to this!
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp Having taught grades 5 & 6 in elementary and middle schools, in my experience K-5 schools are far more effective, age-appropriate, and nurturing. Grade 5 is simply too young to be exposed to developmentally different issues and to also be taken out of a scenario where the 5th graders can now be leaders and gain more confidence, maturity as well as academic competence. We live in a world that already expects our kids to grow up too fast and be too busy, why rush them when we don’t have to? I hope they keep K-5 educational structures as is in SB.
Emily Frazier WilliamsEmily Frazier WilliamsI love the idea Monica but that would be unrealistic for a lot of parents with younger children at home or for those of us with two full-time working adults in the home. The move would need to be based on tangible benefits provided by the school, not parent volunteers. In addition, altho age-appropriate activities might be available, you cannot avoid the fact that they’ll be spending most of their time in the context of older students dealing with puberty, etc. the free play of recess is still developmentally necessary at that age.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby The grade 5/6 house concept is it’s own conversation with many pros and cons. It’s unfortunate we as a community have so many scenarios, budgets, impacts to consider at once – while really each topic is so significant. 
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll A part of me wonders if this idea to spend all this money for a mega-school that may not even fit at the Oak Creek site is really a way for David Young to push through another agenda. People would be more willing to consider a move of the 5th grade if it means saving the elementary schools? I guess I’m just skeptical on many levels as to why there is a great need for major changes in well-performing, well-loved, elementary schools?
Paul Engels  Paul Engels Emilee, I was on the Master Planning and Visioning Task Force. The report from the task force was written by only the chair and the consultant and was never voted on or approved by the task force. Likewise, the minutes of the meetings were never voted on or approved. One meeting was held without a quorum and yet minutes were taken and decisions made.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby The impact to the Chamberlin neighborhood of losing its school is significant to every property owner there. It seems a very premature move at this time. Especially if “city center” is to be the future home of all library/rec/etc, leaving no municipal opportunity for the Chamberlin land??? ALSO I’d like clarification on OPTION 2 – which I believe renovates ALL 5 SB schools to “21st Century Learning”. Seems like the most efficient plan for the next 10 years, in which time hopefully the real “impact” of city center and any potential changes in the airport area are KNOWN and not just ESTIMATED. Our schools should not be the first of the dominos to fall. And I’d much rather know that a city bond to support our library and rec department can be secured. Priorities!!!
Jennifer KochmanJennifer KochmanMonica Ostby, One of the options for recreation facilities would be to re-purpose Chamberlin, and perhaps Orchard, as community centers. Kevin Dorn proposed this to our committee some time ago. Recreation (and Library both) are in need of program space, especially for pre-school and senior programs. There is very little daytime program space. The Chamberlin school as a community center could offer play groups, school readiness, senior programs, and whatever the community requests. Some physical recreation could also be offered. Here are the three things that have been proposed to us: Library/Recreation/City Hall all in City Center; Some facilities in City center, and some in neighborhoods; Some facilities in the Arena. I can see advantages in each of these scenarios. I am not advocating for one or the other here. But Chamberlin as a community center is still on the table as far as I know.
Monica OstbyMonica OstbyI’d hope SOMETHING community based would remain on the table for Chamberlin IF it is decided it will no longer be a school. But from a budgeting standpoint, with Chamberlin not being within the TIF, this will be a continued, greater burden on taxpayers, not included in either the CIP or the School proposal. I look forward to seeing city and school numbers come together. So much to wrap our collective minds around!
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby Clarification on the 5th Grade move – First, Abby Crocker, you were on that committee as well right? From what I understand, the decision to move them was halted not because of parental backlash alone, but because the bigger question of what would happen with City Center – and how it impacts school decisions was unknown. (Thus the creation of the Master Planning Task Force last year.) Personally, I think it was right to delay that decision HOWEVER, as a parent of three kids: grades 11, 9, and 4, I can say I think 5th graders moved into middle school, creating a new “5/6 house” would not only be an excellent advancement for 5th graders, but for 6th graders as well. Much to say on this topic. That said, I do think it’s overall better for the city/taxpayers to renovate our current schools (thus keeping 5th graders in the elems). As a taxpayer, I’d like to see the realities of City Center before closing schools to accommodate it. And if anything, for the schools I’d like to see a new 500 Dorset Street campus – new Middle School & new High School. But clearly that’s not on the table…
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Yes, I was on the 5th grade transition committee and YES the big issue was “why are we talking about this?”. At the time many people questioned whether this was a pre-empt to wanting to close a school….after all what would happen to Chamberlin’s enrollment numbers if they didn’t have the 5th grade? We were re-assured that closing a school was not on the table and this was strictly a discussion around educational benefits….now fast forward 2 years later and yes we’re talking about closing schools. Erg.
Laurel Williams I have heard skepticism from educators about moving the 5th grade into the middle school, which echoes my own personal reservations. I don’t think 5th graders will mellow out the older kids going through the throes of junior high; I think the older kids will make things tougher on the younger, instead. … More broadly, what’s with the pattern of the school administration suggesting, with little to no apparent research, various major upheavals to our elementary schools that don’t have support (expanding the school year, the 5th grade move, and now school consolidation)? If they’re aware of a problem that needs solving, I would like to hear about it and have the community come together to offer solutions. Instead I feel like it’s one attempt at railroading after another, with no clear explanation or motive.

“the other side of the tracks”

As posted on Facebook by Linus Leavens 4/5/16

“Chamberlin was described as being on the “other side of the tracks” in the Task Force Report”…Grrrr! Just read this in a post. Arrogant bastards. So not true.

Chamberlin is the best elementary school in South Burlington. Solid administration, great teachers, & really smart kids. Becca Lee Rosenthal was SBHS valedictorian the year her classmate Hannah Leavens graduated in the top 10. Parenting helps.

Yes, Chamberlin has its share of residents who stay an average of 1.5 years in the neighborhood, but for the settled residents, outcomes really do matter.

Close Central if you must, & build something to replace it (think carefully about actually selling the land- with the Williston Rd curb cuts, it might be worth a lot more later), but leave our neighborhood schools alone!

Comments:
Abby Crocker Abby Crocker –  Linus Leavens having your personal perspective on the value of Chamberlin to the neighborhood as well as your personal experience of how great an education the kids receive at the school is SO important for the school board to hear. Please email them, or go to the meetings and be sure your voice is heard!!!

School Board Hosting Information Sharing Nights

As posted on Facebook by Monica Ostby 4/4/6

This was posted on the SB schools website:

Interested in learning about the options being discussed for your
South Burlington schools?

Please join us!

Following the March 22nd session the School board is hosting three
more opportunities for information sharing.

Dates, times, and locations below:
Tuesday, April 26, 6:30 p.m. – 8:30 p.m., Chamberlin School
Saturday, May 7, 9:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m., Rick Marcotte Central School
Tuesday, May 24, 6:30 p.m. – 8:30 p.m., Orchard School
All are welcome!
Questions? Please call 652-7258

Comments:
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Questions to ask the School Board (Bridget Burkhardt andMartin James LaLonde?): 

1) Will any new information be shared beyond what was already shared at the March 22nd meeting? Specifically, if we went to the March 22nd meeting should we also go to these?

2) What is the process for collecting community input? What will be the process for evaluating the community input received? Will you evaluate the community input in a transparent manner such that we can see how it impacted your decision making process?

Bridget Burkhardt  Bridget Burkhardt Thank you for your questions. We do plan to share additional information as we gather it. We will post any presentations made online and record the sessions on RETN, so it is not necessary to attend all of the sessions in order to feel like you have access to all of the new information. In addition, I would expect we would utilize the Master Planning and Visioning discussion that is a standing agenda item at our regular board meetings to include feedback we’ve received since the last meeting, although we have not formally staked that out as a board. That will begin this week with a brief discussion of the feedback from the March 22nd meeting. A broader discussion of that feedback will take place at the April 13th meeting when we have all board members in attendance (we will be missing two members on Wednesday).

The structure of the community meetings at the schools is not finalized yet but I would expect it to be a presentation (shorter than that at the March 22nd meeting???) followed by discussions. As on the 22nd, I would expect notes will be taken and incorporated into the feedback we are collecting. I hope this answers your questions, but please know that we have not met as a board since the March 22nd meeting so some of this may change and simply reflects my take on where we left things.

Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Thanks Bridget. I think how your are going to collect and interpret community feedback will be important. I am very interested in this process.
Bridget Burkhardt  Bridget Burkhardt We hope to discuss that process at the school board meeting tomorrow. Hopefully you or someone else from the group can come and share notes.

How proposed school costs would impact the ability to bond city center infrastructure

As posted on Facebook by Abby Crocker 4/4/16

I’m wondering what the city council perspective is on some of the proposed school board options – specifically concerning costs. I’m trying to make sense of the school construction bond amounts, how these relate to tax increases and how they would impact the ability to bond for infrastructure to develop city center.

When I think of tax impact from construction bonds I refer to the information we were presented with as part of the Master Visioning Task Force. Briefly, you can estimate that for every $10mill bond it would result in a $33 annual tax increase for every $100k home property value, assuming a 30year bond at a 4.332% interest rate (see page 32 of the Task Force June 3rd report).

So, the School Board’s proposed options would increase annual property taxes by:

$9mill bond: $30/$100k (i.e. increase $90 for a $300k home)
$36mill bond: $119/$100k (i.e. increase $357 for a $300k home)
$64mill bond: $211/$100k (i.e. increase $633 for a $300k home)

Will taxpayers also be asked to approve bonds for city center infrastructure? Will a school construction bond of this magnitude impact our ability to develop city center?

 

 

Comments:
 Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery The City will certainly be asking taxpayers to approved bonds for city center infrastructure. In response to your second question, you all know the answer to that question as well as we do, since we all pay property taxes. The School Board and City Council will be addressing this soon. I’ll let you all know once that meeting date is set.
Bernie Paquette  Bernie Paquette I hope the CC also balances the unfunded and other CIP upcoming costs in relation to the prop tax rate, when considering the creation of a Public Communications staff position.
Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery Just so that it’s clear, the funds for covering this position were passed in the last budget vote. Nevertheless, Bernie’s caution is present in Council discussions.
Bernie Paquette  Bernie Paquette Not to late to re think the position and re prioritize against fixed costs needs.
Candidates spoke of managing city budget with a mind to the property tax rate. Let us see how individual wish list items are balanced against fixed costs not yet met and against holding down prop tax rates. Many lg expenditures upcoming

Improving communications is an important objective for all of us. However I think limited tax revenues need to first cover fixed costs items like restoring the pension fund, CIP structural expenses, and wish lists like boosting the reserve fund.

Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker So what would be an “appropriate” total bond amount to put forth to taxpayers? And, how can we best use those funds to improve the entire city?
Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery There is no magic number. The key is getting the public behind the vision requiring an investment.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Meaghan Elizabeth Emery and choosing the right vision(s).
Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery “right” meaning publicly supported
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker And, “right” means different things to different people .
Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery “right” meaning based on sound policy, which has all sorts of attached factors

It’s a balance of things, and our job as public officials is to make our best effort to explain to the public our reasoning for policy decisions. We must hear where the public is and persuade the public that any given policy serves the public good.

Tim BarrittTim BarrittDon’t forget that the effect of the TIF is to take the property taxes from the new construction and use that to pay for those bonds. The question is probably timing and amount because the construction can’t start until the money comes first and the taxes come a year later (more or less). So I would be bet that taxpayers are on the hook for that lag AND any difference. IT ALL ADDS UP.
Helen Riehle Helen Riehle That is the proverbial $64,000 question which is exactly why a full discussion among the school board, city council and the public is critical. I am confident that the entire council is dedicated to having that discussion. The first take will be at the next Steering Committee meeting. That is yet to have a final date but should be late April or early May.
Thomas Ira Chittenden  Thomas Ira Chittenden I’d offer that I agree with everything on this thread. To answer the two questions originally posed, I’d offer that when it comes to bonding capacity and funding priorities, our school system is paramount. City Center is a great opportunity for South Burlington to create a place for all of us to enjoy and to strengthen our revenue streams which will further strengthen the services & infrastructure that make our schools exceptional. I look forward to supporting the school configuration the residents and the school board decide is best for our kids and our community to then explore how City Center could help support that vision.

Library and Dumont Park Locations…

As posted by Jennifer Kochman on Facebook 4/3/16

I believe someone posted a question about the siting of the Library in City Center, and also in that post mentioned Dumont Park. The City of South Burlington website has two visualizations posted. Go to the city website, scroll down, and on the right, click on “City Center Movie Visualization.” In this scenario, the Library and City Hall are located on the central green space. Dumont Park is the treed green area to the south. This scenario also show a Recreation Center around the corner from the Library. As we know, however, these plans are not firm. There are other plans proposed: the Catamount Arena, locating the Library in the UMall area, locating some recreation/program facilities in re-purposed elementary schools.
Scrolling farther down the City website, click on City Center/Dumont Park. This gives a timeline for Dumont Park. (In my opinion this timeline needs to be updated.)
These two information pieces might be useful for tonight’s City Council discussion of City Center.

 

Comments:
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker It seems like there’s so many balls in the air and things keep changing. Do you know if the reason for focusing on building the library in city center is to be able to leverage TIF funds for it? 

All of the school board options that were presented at the March 22nd meeting that involved closing schools suggested that they sell the school properties (not use them for municipal infrastructure). My guess is because this allowed them to apply the “profits” from selling the schools to the estimated required bond amount.

I’ve often thought the Wheeler House would be a nice library.

Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman – Abby Crocker, You said it! So many balls in the air, and so many interlocking pieces! Yes, the original City Center Task Force, chaired by Bobbie Maynes, recommended studied which of the three municipal buildings should go into City Center, and how they might be arranged. That Task Force recommended that Library, Recreation Facility, and City Hall should all be located in City Center, and all included in one building. And yes, that was to take advantage of 30% TIF financing. Locating the Library in Wheeler would not qualify for TIF; Locating the Recreation Facility in Veterans park would not qualify for TIF. I can tell you that some months ago Kevin Dorn attended a meeting of Recreation and Leisure Arts, and proposed that if Chamberlin and/or Orchard scholols were closed, they might be re-purposed for community/recreation/program facilities. As far as I know, that proposal is still on the table. Our committee did not express an opinion. We were open to the idea. I believe that Kevin Dorn also approached the Library Board to propose that the Library be located in the UMall area. That area is now part of the expanded TIF district. The Arena puts another option in the works. Stay tuned!
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker I should know this…..who owns the green space where the proposed rec, library and city hall would go in city center? Is there city owned land within city center? Or would the city have to buy this? Or would it be “given” to the city by a developer under some agreement?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman I believe that the land (Dumont Park excepted) is not owned by the city. I would love to see a clear explanation of the process of acquiring land, attracting business, and developing the vision for City Center. It would be great to have that posted on the city website, along with whatever information they can share about where each of those issues is in the process.
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp Dumont Park Parcel Map showing 7.65 acres the City purchased in 1975 including trails & mapped wetlands:http://www.sburl.com/…/City_Center_Park_overview.jpg
SBURL.COM

Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman Ilona Blanchard gave an update on City Center at the City Council meeting tonight. I encouraged her to share the power point presentation on the City website. Ilona said she would be willing to present this with discussion at any informal meeting…like a house party.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby Jennifer – Did Ilona include and budget estimates for the municipal projects? It might be a great idea for her to offer to present it after the three meetings the School Board announced so more people can see it?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman No, there were no budget estimates. I would go to the City CIP.

“Information Sharing” vs “Input”?

As posted on Facebook by Monica Ostby 4/4/16

APR26

Tue 6:30 PM · Chamberlin School · South Burlington, VT, United States

Comments
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker Of note…the website said “information sharing” not “input”. My guess is that they will have round table discussions but I think its important to understand what the process will be for community input. Its frustrating to plan to attend these meetings, arrange transportation, pay for babysitters, etc. and then hear members of the administration say that the results are too biased to listen to because the “sample” wasn’t representative. Any volunteer, public input session will produce biased results – but it doesn’t negate the importance of the concerns raised, and its the only opportunity for engaged community members to show up and participate!

Side note….I do not support the idea of a survey. The survey, also volunteer response, may have a higher number of respondents but just because its bigger doesn’t mean its more representative.

Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman This is one of the dates suggested for the Wheeler Park Conservation Easement Committee meeting.
Monica OstbyMonica Ostby – Jennifer, when this date is confirmed regarding Wheeler, can you post it here? i can add it as an event.
Jennifer KochmanJennifer Kochman – Monica Ostby Yes, I will.
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp The process for “collecting” and “recording” participant input at these meetings needs to be very transparent. I am, at this point, wary as the FAQ information the School Board promised to deliver to the public has not appeared anywhere–website, the Other Paper–yet. Where are the answers to the questions that were asked at the 3/22 meeting? It’s very frustrating that the process seems less than transparent.

Language, Enrichment, and $$$

As posted by Scott Baker 4/2/16
(Note – The initial post was about Foreign Language, but the comments went way beyond…)

To Abby Crocker‘s post on language: here’s an article from The Atlantic about America’s lacking language skills, yet more than half of VTs total exports and 1 in 5 jobs are tied to international trade (and growing). If we want to help grow our economy AND keep some of our graduates in VT, language is critical.

Budget cuts, low enrollments, and teacher shortages mean the country is falling behind the rest of the world.
WWW.THEATLANTIC.COM|BY AMELIA FRIEDMAN

Comments
Ashley Tarkington  Ashley Tarkington I found it surprising when I traveled to Honduras that my Spanish was about as good as the average person’s English (I took 4 years starting back in 1999). Both were barely functional. This was in the second poorest country in Central America, second to Haiti. I came home feeling like we/I could do better.
Scott H Baker  Scott H Baker This data is 3 years old but referenced in my post:http://tradepartnership.com/…/2015/01/VT_TRADE_2013.pdf
Meaghan Elizabeth Emery  Meaghan Elizabeth Emery At a Francophone event I attended last Thursday in Burlington, a Quebec envoy stated that there is currently $4 billion of business transactions annually between Vermont and Quebec and that 90,000 jobs in Vermont are connected to this business relationship. These numbers are confirmed by this pdf document.
Duncan Scott Adamson  Duncan Scott Adamson I completely agree. But I don’t buy the argument that the only way for our kids to learn a second language is at a consolidated elementary school.
Scott H Baker  Scott H Baker Agreed
Erin Hooper Sutherland  Erin Hooper Sutherland Agree. Strong leadership can figure out how to accommodate three elementary schools. The mount Mansfield district has many elementary schools.
Scott H Baker  Scott H Baker A list of research-based evidence on the impact of immersion and language programs, some of which link improved math and science proficiency due to language study: http://www.actfl.org/…/discover-languages/resources-5
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker What can we do to let our school board and our administration know that we want what’s best for the children of SB, but we do not believe that we need to spend $64million on a new building to achieve this. Can we please shift the conversation to explore non facilities improvements for optimizing educational opportuiites?
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp Yes, please!!
Monica Ostby Monica Ostby The challenge is that the current budget is maxed out without the Act 46 ‘penalty’ tax coming into play. (School Budgets get the penalty – BONDs do not.) We as a town can say that we’re willing to pay the penalty to add whatever programming we want, but will voters support that? The whole point of consolidation was supposed to be to reduce expense so we could add such programming – but clearly consolidation itself eats up too much expense to expect already too-heavily taxed residents add more. Especially if City issues like Library, Rec Dept, etc are also still being discussed. What I want to know from the Martin James LaLonde – as our State Rep AND our School Board member is are there “special educational benefits” we can pay for with a BOND? Such as 10 years worth of Foreign Language teacher contracts, and Executive Function. This whole education budgeting process is very frustrating – and I think we need to even put pressure on Gubernatorial candidates. Serious. If Act 46 is meant to create equity across the state… how can RICHMOND have Foreign Language in it’s ES – and not SB? What’s equal $$ or education? I say we need to pressure the STATE (perhaps via Jim Condos – SOS & former SB City Councilor) to give towns the flexibility to use BONDS to pay for what we want!!! (Not just construction!!!)
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker But are we truly using our existing resources effectively? How are other communities able to make foreign language, coordinated volunteer math programs, professional development and individualized education work (without suggesting that tearing down schools and building a $64million facility is the only way)?

Are we lean with our budget? Are we supporting individuals to do their best? Are we holding them accountable when they aren’t?

How much of our school budget is spent on consultants? Having served on the 5th grade transition committee and the master visioning task force I am aware of at least 4 different consultants used just for this facility discussion. THAT money alone would fund a foreign language FTE.

Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby This Abby, is why I’m so grateful Bridget Burkhardt has stepped up to the plate! smile emoticon
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp  – Martin James LaLonde Just how close to being maxed out via Act 46 are we? Did the social work positions, and others that were proposed pass in this budget? My concern is that foreign language was cut years ago and now social service type positions are being added or proposed?
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby This is part of the problem. The needs (and Fed mandates) have changed significantly since that time. There was a wonderful cross-school after school foreign language program that had support from the SB Community Fund. It was wonderful. But it takes parents to keep it going. I’d love to see it back in motion again.
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll If I remember correctly from the teacher strike, aren’t our teachers paid some of the highest salaries in the state? Could this be a major difference in our budget as compared to others with foreign language? Just curious. Also, it frustrates me that a decent amount of money has been spent on all of these consultants as well. I wish that money was spent on our children or improving our aging buildings instead.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker What about our administration? How much do they get paid compared to others in the state? How much of our per pupil spending goes into salaries/benefits vs programs compared to other districts?
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll Yes, that’s exactly what I’m wondering. I would expect salaries to be higher based on the cost of living/high taxes in SB but I wonder if this is what is preventing us from programs such as foreign language?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman Thank you for posting this article. I believe that the School/City Task Force suggested that one of the advantages of a consolidated elementary school is that “enrichment courses” like languages, music, art, etc. could be offered more efficiently, and to more students.
Laurel Williams  Laurel Williams That’s what they suggested, but there wasn’t a lot of evidence for it — especially after the costs for consolidation were modeled to be especially high. How do we know (versus just thinking) there will be money and resources to enrich elementary courses?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman That’s a good question. If they do go for consolidation, I would certainly expect them to follow through on offering enrichment.
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker But in order to “efficiently offer programs” we need to spend $64million on a facility? And, with all the negatives that come with closing schools can’t we figure out how to more efficiently offer programs across schools? This retains our healthy neighborhood anchors and doesnt cost tens of millions of dollars. Other districts (such as Mt Mansfield) can do this….why can’t we?
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman I want to begin to play Devil’s Advocate for the sake of another opinion here. The difference in cost between Scenario #2 ($41 M) and Scenario #4 ($51 M) is $10 M: a quarter of #2, and a fifth of #4. Plus you would have a school configured to 21st century learning modes.
Laurel WilliamsLaurel WilliamsBut what does that really mean, Jennifer — 21st century learning modes? My kids use Chromebooks at Orchard now. I saw the presentation images of “breakout spaces” and “makerspaces” but no real discussion of how such spaces would be used to radically c…See More
Jennifer KochmanJennifer Kochman – Laurel Williams I saw the 3/22 public meeting as an overview, and not the in depth discussion that would answer your comment. This would be a good question for follow-up at the next public event on schools.
Monica OstbyMonica OstbyI think Scenario #2 includes upgrading the current three to “21 Century Learning” as well. So, unless I’m wrong, only Scenario #1 does not incorporate 21st Century Learning. I’ll ask this question at the next School Board Meeting this Tuesday 4/6.
Laurel WilliamsLaurel Williams – Jennifer Kochman This could be. My impression is the process has gone some ways already and a vote is sought in the fall. So my fear is this is it and no one intends to dive further. I will certainly write up these concerns for the school board and others though.
Monica Ostby  Monica Ostby  – Jennifer Kochman – “Enrichment” was mentioned in terms of number of FTEs available due to some shifting. But it’s very limited numbers. This is where there is great confusion – though a snazzy soundbite. Sure, a FTE or 2 may be readjusted, but at an incremental bond-repayment expense of $500 per $355,000 home value to residents. There are far more efficient ways to deliver enrichment to students. Especially if this BOND issue can be dealt with. I’m hearing some crazy soundbites out there… like a NEW SWIMMING POOL BEING ADDED IN THE “NEW BUILDING” AT OAK CREEK?! (What?) I hope the School Board can deliver a reality check at the upcoming community meetings. Severely lacking at this point.
Jennifer Kochman  Jennifer Kochman I have no knowledge of any proposal for a swimming pool at Oak Creek. And no, I don’t consider enrichment for language, music, art, etc. a soundbite.
Kate Griffin Nahstoll  Kate Griffin Nahstoll  – Jennifer Kochman– do you currently have elementary age students? I only ask because I have been pretty satisfied with the level of teaching my daughter has received. Yes, there is always room for improvement (would love to see some foreign language, etc) but I don’t feel we are lacking enough to justify such a huge change and addition of debt.
Jennifer KochmanJennifer KochmanI don’t have children in elementary school. We moved to SB in 1987 when our youngest was a freshman, partly for the schools. I’m glad you are happy with the education your children receive now. I do believe that language, music, art, etc. should be taught to all students in the lower grades, and offered in the middle and high school grades.
Music, art, library, mindfulness, health, and PE are all currently taught at Orchard. Foreign language would be the big one that is lacking as far as I know. Also, no orchestra or band.Monica Ostby, Abby Crocker– other than language, what else are we really lacking? Only asking because I’m wondering what I’m missing that could/would be offered in a consolidated school…(what opportunities would be gained for my kids?).
Abby Crocker  Abby Crocker And….there is far more evidence and research to suggest that keeping our 3 elementary schools is the best thing to do for our kids and our community. It is irresponsible to suggest we need a $64million building.
Jennifer KochmanJennifer KochmanThis kind of remark is exactly the reason I have been reluctant to comment or ask questions about the school issues on this Facebook site. Apparently I am not the only person who feels that way because here I see a handful of people talking to each other, and calling irresponsible the only person so far to even play devil’s advocate or ask a question.
Monica OstbyMonica OstbyI read Abby’s comment to ask whether a $64M building is responsible – not accuse you of being irresponsible. There are big changes and big tax impacts on the table. Your voice is important here – especially given your involvement in the needs of the other City concerns such as the library and rec department/center. Let’s not have an us/them situation. I hope you not only stay involved, but invite others with different points of view to participate. It would be far better for our community to feel we worked through these important issues together. And that might not be easy.
Abby CrockerAbby CrockerMonica is right. I was not calling the comment irresponsible and I’m sorry if it was interpreted that way. I do not think the tax payers can afford a $64million bond for a new school building.
Cari Bruley Papp  Cari Bruley Papp I’m surprised that the District is still recommending consolidation, given that the educational data doesn’t support it and the financial price tag is so high. Seems like a very risky proposal to support!